Thursday, September 29, 2011

On Pink Slips for Fashion Challenged New Yorkers

On Tuesday, our public employees union turned down a contract that would have raised health care costs, frozen pay and required that we take unpaid leave.  I know that many people were planning to vote for the contract, none because it was a good contract, but because they were willing to take one for the team. Others were planning to vote yes out of fear for their jobs or out of a sense of responsibility for others who might lose their jobs.  In all, over 16,000 people were willing to sacrifice and voted for the contract.  Another 19,000 were not willing to make those concessions.  In general, they believed it unfair for state workers to have to sacrifice their quality of life in tough times because of a problem they didn’t create, especially when other proposals to balance the budget were not being considered.
It was a stunning outcome because Governor Cuomo threatened that thousands of state workers would be laid off if we didn't accept the contract, and he wasted no time proving that he’s making good on his threat.  The first batch of pink slips were sent out just a day after the ballots were tallied. In what felt like a scene from a dystopian farce, yesterday’s top news stories included updates on campaigning politician’s plans for creating jobs, and our lay-offs.  On the internet, where I expected to find outrage about the irony of laying off thousands of workers during an ongoing unemployment crisis, I found dozens of blog posts and tweets offering victim-blaming opinions that “do-nothing” state workers were finally getting what they deserve. 
At some level, I get the negativity toward state workers.  When I moved to Albany, my dad suggested I apply for a state job.  I thought that was a ridiculous proposal.  Like many, I believed state workers were unfashionable, lazy, losers who "work to rule".  But because it seems like everything I mock eventually happens to me (that's why I never make fun of bald people), within a few months of moving upstate I did take a state job.  The man who hired me predicted I would spend the rest of my career working for the government.  I remember that in my head, I laughed at his silly prediction. Fresh out of grad school, sporting Ayn Rand ideals, I was willing to slum for a few months until something grander came along , but I wasn’t going to be an actual state worker.  

That was 18 years ago and I'm now known as a "lifer".  I still work for the state; a bit less fresh and ideal, but possibly a smidge wiser.  Over close to two decades of civil service, I learned that most of my earlier ideas about civil servants were wrong; we're an eclectic bunch, pretty much like everyone else. I guess I have to admit that as a group we’re not as fashion forward as our private sector peers, but we’re not lazy and don’t “work to rule”.  We just show up each day and put in an honest day’s work serving the public - you know, helping people. 
So I do understand the general beliefs about civil servants, but I don’t get how that translates to all this vitriolic anger toward us in the midst of a national job crisis?  It can’t all be about our poor fashion sense.  Do people think that state jobs are not real jobs, or that state workers don’t have lives and families to support?  Are unemployed government workers different than other unemployed people, such that their unemployment is ok while other people’s unemployment amounts to a national crisis? Or is it possible that people think we deserve to suffer because WE are the evil government? 
Maybe it doesn’t matter what other people think, and maybe I should pretend not to notice that the anger we’re seeing in today’s economic crisis is reminiscent of the seeds of discontent that led to wars and acts of horror throughout history.  Because, as this blog is titled, I’m trying really hard to be optimistic.  Maybe going though with lay-offs at a moment in time when creating jobs is our nation’s greatest priority is actually part of the Governor’s grand plan for job creation.  Remember earlier this year when Governor Cuomo killed the millionaire’s tax because the wealthy are job creators who can’t bear the burden of additional taxes?  (Let’s ignore for a moment how odd it is that he's supporting President Obama’s federal millionaire’s tax, because any speculation on that brings out the cynic in me.)  Maybe the Governor's plan is for each person's pink slip to come with a list of the millionaire job creators who will hire them!  That would sure makes sense, since the revenue the state is forfeiting so the millionaires can perform their job creating activities is being offset by our lay-offs. 
On the other hand, I just heard that sales are up at those high end retail stores where state workers can’t afford to shop, even during good times – the ones that sell the designer clothes civil servants aren’t wearing.  What if the millionaires aren't creating jobs, but they’re shopping? 

No comments:

Post a Comment